{
  "run_id": "r-20260507-010321",
  "generated_at": "2026-05-07",
  "generator": "MD Tier 4 Mitigation Designer (M3 routed via Bash)",
  "panel_consensus": {
    "strongest": [
      {"advocate": "P22-the-researcher", "panels_in_top3": ["TP", "UP", "RP"],
       "rationale": "Only advocate appearing in 3 of 4 panels' top-3. Rigor + Limitations + citations resonate broadly."}
    ],
    "secondary": [
      {"advocate": "P12-the-privacy-hawk", "panels_in_top3": ["BP", "RP"],
       "rationale": "Threat-model evidence + on-device privacy framing. BP elevates as Impact narrative anchor."}
    ],
    "category_anchors": {
      "impact_education_1순위": {
        "primary": "P14-the-educator",
        "supporting": ["P15-the-community-builder", "P12-the-privacy-hawk"],
        "note": "User confirmed 1순위 is Impact-Education. BP top-3 maps directly. P14 is the lead pedagogy voice."
      },
      "technical_2순위_backup": {
        "primary": "P25-the-ai-native",
        "supporting": ["P13-the-data-nerd", "P22-the-researcher"],
        "note": "TP top-3. Must NOT lead — serves as backup proof beneath Impact hero."
      },
      "aesthetic_validators": {
        "primary": "P05-the-design-forward",
        "supporting": ["P18-the-designer"],
        "note": "UP top-3. Gate monochrome 1-bit halftone fidelity."
      }
    },
    "panel_divergence_summary": "TP↔BP sharpest split (Technical evidence vs Impact narrative). User 1순위 Impact-Education → BP signal carries extra weight at H1."
  },
  "hard_fixes_for_chosen": [
    {"id": "M01", "severity": "high", "scope": "any preview citing entitlements",
     "concern": "P24 entitlements key error — `device.microphone` is not valid macOS entitlement key.",
     "fix": "verify key is `com.apple.security.device.audio-input`. Cross-check against apps/macos/HeWasSocrates/Resources/HeWasSocrates.entitlements.",
     "verification": "grep chosen HTML for `device.microphone` literal — must be 0 hits."},
    {"id": "M02", "severity": "high", "scope": "any preview using semantic color tokens",
     "concern": "Multi-color violations flagged by UP — P02/P15/P14/P08 violate monochrome 1-bit halftone aesthetic.",
     "fix": "reduce to monochrome bone accent only. Replace semantic colors with halftone-density / text-prefix markers (✓/✕/!).",
     "verification": "computed-style audit: only ink, bone, and halftone gray ramp permitted."},
    {"id": "M03", "severity": "medium", "scope": "all previews mentioning wondering log / Phase 4",
     "concern": "Phase 4 wondering log shown as if shipped (UP + RP cross-flag).",
     "fix": "mark Phase 4 multi-year recall explicitly as designed-for. Use roadmap badge or `Phase 4 (designed)` label.",
     "verification": "every wondering-log mention within 1 sibling of `designed`/`roadmap` marker."},
    {"id": "M04", "severity": "high", "scope": "all previews",
     "concern": "Anti-pattern flagged by BP — Technical-first hero violates user's confirmed Impact-Education 1순위.",
     "fix": "Lead section MUST be Impact-Education narrative. Technical evidence appears below the fold.",
     "verification": "first 1.5 viewport-heights contain Impact-Education vocabulary; Technical specs need Impact framing sentence preceding them."},
    {"id": "M05", "severity": "medium", "scope": "all previews",
     "concern": "Korean tone leakage — 단정한 평어체 must not bleed into chrome/UI text.",
     "fix": "Korean restricted to: (a) system-prompt excerpt block, (b) defer_to_human demo dialogue, (c) bust subtitle.",
     "verification": "any Korean glyph outside three permitted surfaces fails."},
    {"id": "M06", "severity": "medium", "scope": "all previews citing metrics",
     "concern": "RP rigor — uncited metrics undermine credibility.",
     "fix": "every metric (TTFT, RAM, model size, latency floor) must include source path or `measured on M1 Max` qualifier.",
     "verification": "each numeric claim has adjacent citation, footnote, or measurement-context phrase."}
  ],
  "composite_opportunity": {
    "rationale": "No single advocate is Pareto-optimal. Composite leveraging structural strengths from four advocates may outperform verbatim picks.",
    "shell": {"advocate": "P15-the-community-builder", "contribution": "workspace shell layout — sidebar nav + content pane"},
    "content": {"advocate": "P14-the-educator", "contribution": "pedagogy framing + Impact-Education hero — serves 1순위"},
    "evidence": {"advocate": "P12-the-privacy-hawk", "contribution": "threat model + on-device privacy proof"},
    "rigor": {"advocate": "P22-the-researcher", "contribution": "Limitations + citations + measured-not-claimed phrasing"},
    "technical_backup": {"advocate": "P25-the-ai-native or P13-the-data-nerd", "contribution": "below-fold technical evidence block"},
    "aesthetic_gate": {"advocate": "P05-the-design-forward", "contribution": "monochrome 1-bit halftone fidelity check"},
    "h1_decision_options": [
      "OPTION A: P22 verbatim (strongest cross-panel consensus, rigor-first)",
      "OPTION B: P14 verbatim (BP lead, Impact-first, aligns with user 1순위)",
      "OPTION C: composite (P15 shell + P14 content + P12 evidence + P22 rigor + P25 below-fold + P05 aesthetic) — highest expected quality, synthesis effort",
      "OPTION D: P12 verbatim (privacy-first Impact + RP rigor)",
      "OPTION E: user picks other from 26"
    ]
  },
  "h1_gate_constraints": [
    "Lead = Impact-Education (M04)",
    "Korean restricted to identity surfaces (M05)",
    "All metrics cited with source (M06)",
    "Phase 4 marked designed-for (M03)",
    "Monochrome only (M02)",
    "Entitlements key correctness (M01)",
    "3 Gemma 4 load-bearing features referenced (configurable thinking, 256K context, native function-calling)",
    "abstention mechanic (defer_to_human) is the product"
  ],
  "spec_dd_handoff_notes": "After H1: lock chosen HTML structure as delta `runs/2026-05-05-spec/spec/iter<N>-preview-publication.md` (never edit frozen spec). Define GitHub Pages publication path + CI gate. Verify M01-M06 pass before publish."
}